Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Should Batman Villains Betray Each Other? (Analysis using the Prisoner's Dilemma)

(This is the second part of a post that will include some very light and simple algebra and game theoretic concepts. Not to worry--it is pretty crude and easy to follow along with. Also, please note that the assumptions made are rudimentary and based off of my own view of Batman and his villains. I welcome everyone to debate them with me).

Reprinted from http://fansided.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/batmanfoes.jpg
We've discussed the decision of whether or not Batman villains should cooperate. Now consider another fun issue: lets suppose some of them do, in fact, work together and somehow manage to capture the Batman. There is now another decision that has to be made by each: whether or not to betray the partner.

Let's talk about Two-Face this time. As discussed in the previous post, the benefits of betrayal are obvious. Two-Face could claim full credit for killing Batman, could win the respect of the Gotham underworld, could elicit fear from the elite, and could potentially acquire some wealth and technology from the Batcave that he would not have to share with, say, Mr. Freeze (I can't think of a conceivable reason for that pair to team up, but I haven't used Mr. Freeze anywhere yet).

This situation is a nice example of the Prisoner's Dilemma. So, let's do a really quick summation of this two-player (Two-Face, Mr. Freeze), two-choice (Cooperate, Betray) game in Batman terms to show that it would actually make sense for the two of them to continue to cooperate, even though neither will. We must again assign some utilities for each player. I have done so, as the following normal-form game matrix represents:

Mr. Freeze -->>
Two-Face ↓
Cooperate
Betray
Cooperate
(5,5)
(0,10)
Betray
(10,0)
(3,3)

In this matrix, Two-Face is the player on the left and Mr. Freeze is the player on the top. Each has the choice of either cooperating after capturing Batman or of betraying the other. In each cell, the numbers represent the utilities awarded to the respective players given their choice of action.

If both villains cooperate with one another, they each enjoy a utility of 5 from killing Batman and ruling Gotham (5,5). If Two-Face cooperates but Mr. Freeze betrays, then we will assume that Freeze will eliminate Two-Face, thereby winning all of his utility. In this case, Two-Face would get 0 utility and Mr. Freeze would get a utility of 10 (0,10). If Two-Face betrays but Mr. Freeze cooperates, then the opposite happens: Two-Face gets a utility of 10 and Freeze gets 0 (10,0). If they both betray each other, I'm going to assume that they'll either kill each other (in which case they'd both get 0) or they'll both walk away alive, but each would get less utility than they would have if they had cooperated (obviously they'd prefer not to engage in a near-death battle with one another, so they would lose something). Lets award each a utility of 3 in this situation (3,3).

If this is the scenario, each player would rationally want to betray the other. To see this, we must note that Two-Face and Mr. Freeze are hopelessly self-interested. They only care about their own utilities and not that of the other player. Now assume Mr. Freeze decides to cooperate. So we are restricted to the "cooperate" column of the table above. Looking at Two-Face's utilities in that column, it is clearly a better decision for him to betray, as he would be receiving a utility of 10 as opposed to 5. Let's say Mr. Freeze decides to betray, so we are now in the "betray" column. The best decision for Two-Face is still to betray, as he would receive a utility of 3 instead of 0. Hence regardless of what Mr. Freeze does, Two-Face would still want to betray him. The same is true for Mr. Freeze given Two-Face's actions.

Both players will choose to betray each other and (3,3) is the Nash equilibrium outcome. This means that neither Two-Face nor Mr. Freeze can benefit by deviating from his course of action alone. The dilemma, however, is that there exists an outcome in which both players are strictly better off. If both choose to cooperate, then each receive a utility of 5, which is greater than 3. Thus the outcome (5,5) is the Pareto Optimal point. It is the outcome of the game in which one player deviating would necessarily mean that somebody else is worse off.

So, what we have is a scenario in which Two-Face and Mr. Freeze teamed up and were successful (for some reason). Now it would benefit both of them to continue working together, but neither of them will actually do so. Hence they'll walk away with less than what they could have. As the Prisoner's Dilemma demonstrates, Nash Equilibria are not necessarily Pareto Optima. It's sort of funny to think about, actually. Batman can still claim a small victory even in his death.

71 comments:

E said...

Good analysis. One addition I would make is the possibility of cooperation in the infinitely repeated version of the game (which actually isnt that far fetched, given how long the comic has been going on and how many failed attempts at killing the batman each of these villains has made)

For the infinitely repeated case, we'd be comparing the probability of cooperation in each period vs. a one-stage deviation giving a payout of 10 and then 3 afterwards (as both decide to defect forever).

Doing a bit of math we need 5/(1-d) > 10+ 3d/(1-d) where d is the discount rate. Solving gives d > 5/7.

So if the comic runs long enough and villains dont discount future gains that much, then we should be seeing some more evil team-ups.

Allen Varney said...

Two-Face, of course, wouldn't decide whether or not to betray, but would simply choose randomly by flipping a coin.

Anonymous said...

So, Two-face would be random, which would make Mr. Freeze's best bet be betrayal even in an infinite repetition scenario, right? Since he can't rely on Two-Face thinking about the future.

Erik Siegrist said...

Wouldn't the utility of a double betrayal be zero for both villains, since that would inevitably give Batman the opportunity he needs to turn the tables on them... ?

Anonymous said...

Not really Erik, in this scenario they have already defeated Batman.

Peter said...

Great post, but I wonder ...many supervillains (and Batman's villains in particular) seem to be psychotically fixated on the hero's death, beyond any utility from having him out of the way. In any case, Batman's death in itself is a non-rival, non-excludable good, right? It's only the utility of *being the one who killed him* that has to be allocated. So if we imagine a case where this is positive but negligible compared to the utility of having him dead, and betrayal introduces some small risk of failure to kill him, couldn't we get much closer to a point of indifference between betrayal and cooperation?

(if it's not obvious by now I was a C student in economics, so maybe i'm thinking about this wrong...)

pete

Tom said...

Excellent! I move that this post be emailed immediately to DC and incorporated into a story wherein Batman is captured by two villains and, using the Prisoner's Dilemna argument, persuades them to betray each other in order to faciliate his escape.

Anonymous said...

I suppose you can say the probability of Two-Face betraying Freeze would be 50%. His decision is entirely based on the coin...

Anonymous said...

This scenario is a good example of the limits of models. In this case we're taking the generic and generically rational 'prisoners' and replacing them with specific individuals. Specifically, irrationally psychotic individuals.

Mr. Freeze is focused on the long-term goal of either (Depending on which version we're talking about) reviving his cryogenically preserved wife or avenging the horrible slow death of his wife who's frozen corpse he keeps as a momento. To betray or not to betray depends on how the decision serves this goal. Killing Batman is a side-course, not the main dish.

Two-Face is dependent on his coin to make major decisions. Rational utility doesn't even enter the picture.

The Joker... Who is stupid enough to think they can team up with the Joker and not get burned? The man tortures people to death for the lulz.

Models and game theory are useful tools, but all tools have limits. This post is a great example of the limits of the Prisoner's Dilemma.

Arkain said...

@Anonymous Poster Above Me

While there is room for psychology, you are missing the point of the chart. Each villain, with or without predisposition for betrayal (which I would argue they all have to some degree) and with all else remaining equal (IE: the death of Batman and it's immediate rewards being the only motivation for the team up), then it is logically beneficial to the villains to betray each other, regardless of their personal choice (or impersonal in Two-Face's case). It could also be argued that rational players would choose the 5-5 split because of the guarantee of safety by continual mutual gain (assuming that cooperation implies further criminal activities). Batman villains, as you explained, are irrational and would likely deviate from this rational course of action.

viagra online said...

let me think about this, the Joker is a total maniac, Penguin is so greed, Cat women is to sexy, yes all the villains betrays each to others, no matter how many time this character want join force against the dark knight the results is the same always.

Cris said...

This information is very interesting, I really enjoyed, I would like get more information about this, because is very beautiful, thanks for sharing! costa rica investment opportunities

niz said...

Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

Green Parks said...

Hello.. Firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Green Parks Costa Rica in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

xiaoxia said...

power balance ® holograms are designed to work with your body's natural energy
field.This is your best choose for the coming Christmas.Enjoy winter Boots onlinenewshop.

Penis Enlargement Pills said...

I am thoroughly convinced in this said post. I am currently searching for ways in which I could enhance my knowledge in this said topic you have posted here. It does help me a lot knowing that you have shared this information here freely. I love the way the people here interact and shared their opinions too. I would love to track your future posts pertaining to the said topic we are able to read.

buy kamagra online said...

Hi,
Thanks for posting this blog..Really I like it ..Thanks for posting this blog.

Generic Viagra Online said...

Nice....
Analysis using the Prisoner's Dilemma
Thanks

sim so dep said...

I have to say, I dont know if its the clashing colours or the dangerous grammar, however this weblog is hideous! I imply, I dont need to sound like a know-it-all or anything, however could you could have presumably put a little bit extra effort into this subject. Its really fascinating, but you dont signify it well at all, man. Anyway, in my language, there usually are not much good supply like t

quality backlinks said...

Great write-up, I am a giant believer in commenting on blogs to help the blog writers know that they?ve added something worthwhile to the world wide net! (supply roblox-cheats.com). Anyway, in my language, there should not much good supply like this.

link wheel said...

I used to be questioning if you would like to be a visitor poster on my web site? and in trade you may embody a hyperlink your post? Please reply when you get an opportunity and I will send you my contact particulars - thanks. Anyway, in my language, there aren't much good source like this.

download movie said...

This is really appealing. After reading it you have made me think a bit because you mentioned a few really great facts. This is very enlightening.

custom logo design said...

I found so numerous interesting stuff in your weblog particularly its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment right here! keep up the good function.

irs back taxes said...

I admire the way you express yourself through writing. Your post is such a refreshing one to read. This is such an interesting and informative article to share with others. Keep up the good work and more power. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

I been browsing through different sites each day and yours is an interesting one. We may differ in beliefs and interest but I surely could relate in your way of writing. I’m looking forward to read and as well as share some knowledgeable information with you soon.

loans till payday | android app developers

Cialis Generico said...

Nice post!! Thanks for sharing!!

Karlo tagalog said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
wordpress premium themes said...

I am a giant believer in commenting on blogs to help the blog writers know that they?ve added something worthwhile to the world wide net! (supply roblox-cheats.com). Anyway, in my language, there should not much good supply like this.

FSNB Online Banking said...

If they work together they wouldn't be able to take credit for the fiasco.

Inversiones en petroleo said...

hello, i think that this post is the best that i have read.

abercrombiefitch said...

Be fast to browse the newest styles and lots of affordable outfits and Nike oxygen Max and women's merchandise is not an daily affair, for that reason that in the stress of modern day time girls ordinarily do not possess a complete great offer time and vitality to go buying by means of countless many style malls, and look at special fees will make you exhausted, so which you can acquire a satisfactory goods, call up for to devote lots of time, the show up of on collection buying significantly minimizing the inconvenience of this, now you not just can every one of the sudden go to to lots of goods Nike Air Max Shoes .

Cialis Generika kaufen said...

Difficult decision. I would faith make the choice.
I know everybody is raving about Heath Ledger as the Joker and don't get me wrong he is brilliant but for me the one and only joker will be Jack Nicholson.

pembe maske said...

I am a giant believer in commenting on blogs to help the blog writers know that they?ve added something worthwhile to the world wide net! (supply roblox-cheats.com). Anyway, in my language, there should not much good supply like this.pembe maskeenergy balance

static website design said...

You have really made it interesting by doing a great analysis the way you did it was amazing.

ac repair lorton said...

Its very intersting to read about the Batman betray with each other and how it can be negative for anybody and also what could be results of these actions.

hot_girl said...

choi sim thi cac bạn tham khao

Sunglasses UK said...

I have been really glad after reading this blog as the knowledge which has been given via this blog is simply tremendous. I would congratulate and appreciate the blogger for doing this much hard work.

Sunglasses UK | Polarized Sunglasses | aviator sunglasses | Designer Sunglasses | Polarised Sunglasses | aviator sunglasses

sim so dep said...

Two-Face is dependent on his coin to make major decisions. Rational utility doesn't even enter the picture.

xanax prescription said...

Wow! It's awesome blog post here. really very interesting for reading.Like those pictures.. I enjoyed it.

Gerald said...

this page | here | there | check this | this sitehere | this page | there
this site | check this | here | this page | therecheck this | this site
this page | here | there | check this | this sitehere | this page | there

lesbian bondage said...

Great website, looks very clean and organized.

ehic said...

interesting article

ehic said...

interesting article

water bondage said...

Interesting! although I have no expert, but I want have to know more and more, on your blog just interesting and useful information. Keep it up!

inversiones en oro said...

Wow, nice post,there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post.Thank you for sharing to us.Please one more post about that..

bondage sex said...

Great website, looks very clean and organized. And very interesting to read Your the article!

lesbian wrestling said...

I want have to know more and more, on your blog just interesting and useful information.

Watch Free Movies Blog said...

It will use a double betrayal of zero to two villains, which inevitably will have a chance to Batman, tables, in their

red kitchenaid mixer said...

intersting to read , good job

cell monitoring said...

If you think about it, there's a massive amount of government funds especially in the area of genetic and other engineering of humans as soldiers.
android phone tracking
android spy
android gps tracking

feathered hair extensions said...

great comic villains

negocios rentables said...

hello, i would like to read more about this interesting topic beacuase
it is really interesting.

Sebastian said...

This cannot succeed in reality, that is exactly what I suppose.
ceramic straighteners | salsa recipe | hardest game ever

sexshoptienda.blogspot.com said...

Really useful material, lots of thanks for your post.

adlai said...

wow. .interesting topic in your post. . thanks for sharing to us. . keep it up. ..
phone spy software for the safety of my phone.Android phone locator for the tracking of my location.
android gps apps locator and tracking my route.

android tracker also a tracker for my gps.

cell phone tracker software
cell phone monitoring
cell phone spyware
cell phone spy software
cell spy now review
spyware for cell phones

Anonymous said...

phone number lookup

best online pharmacy said...

I am also interested in this topic. I have spent a lot of time on searching this kind of topic. It is very informative.

Web Page Optimization said...

I suppose you can say the probability of Two-Face betraying Freeze would be 50%. His decision is entirely based on the coin...

the best seo company said...

Very significant article for us ,I think the representation of this article is actually superb one. This is my first visit to your site

buy lortab online said...

The positive comments and do well wishes are very motivational and greatly appreciated.

buy ritalin online said...

This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

buy medicine said...

I'm still learning from you, but I'm trying to achieve my goals. I certainly enjoy reading all that is posted on your blog.Keep the information coming. I loved it!

buy online percocet said...

The positive comments and do well wishes are very motivational and greatly appreciated.

buy codeine online said...

I am also interested in this topic. I have spent a lot of time on searching this kind of topic. It is very informative.

viagra without prescription said...

Thanks mate... just dropped by. Will look for BIKE STN when we get to Seattle. Still in Buenos Airies.

under eye wrinkles said...

Your post is really good. Hard stool remedies White spots on skin Stomach gas problems

Anonymous said...

louis vuitton replica for sale designer handbags.
replica louis vuitton antheia for sale.
replica Mahina Leather handbags for sale.
replica Monogram Canvas for sale.
replica Monogram denim for sale.
Cheap Monogram Macassar Canvas for sale.
Replica louis vuitton monogram multicolore for sale.
replica Monogram Purses for sale.
replica Monogram Purses for sale.
replica Monogram Vernis bags for sale.

Tariq said...

If you want to buy xanax online then I think you are at right place mycare pharmacy is one of the best pharmacy . Here you can buy medicines at very cheap rates as like buy ritalin online and many more .

philip said...

Such a nice one.thanks for sharing.



penegra Online

organic seo service said...

This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

Anonymous said...

Nike air force shoes shoes for sale.
air force 1 cheap online sale!
air force 1 livestrong online sale!
cheap air force 1 low online sale!
womens air force 1 online sale!